Chapter three – Methodology
3.1 | Philosophical Foundations
In order to measure how this survey will continue in relation to its philosophical foundation, it is of import to measure the research paradigms that are available through this survey. A research paradigm is ‘a set of common beliefs and understandings about the universe shared by a community of scientists about how jobs should be understood and addressed ( Weaver and Olson, 2006, p.406 ) . There are a figure of scientific research paradigms ; nevertheless this treatment will concentrate on two, viz. ; Realism and Constructivism, of which both vary in footings of ontology and epistemology ( Cole, 1997 ) .
Epistemology is the subdivision of doctrine concerned with the nature and range of cognition ( Alston, 2989 ) . Put briefly, it is the survey of cognition and justified belief. It inquiries what cognition is and how it can be acquired, and the extent to which knowledge pertinent to any given topic or entity can be acquired. Conversely, Ontology is the philosophical survey of world. By this Ontology refers to the ‘nature of being, going, being or reality’ ( Harvey, 2006, p.341 ) .
Harmonizing to Parsons ( 2010, p.80 ) , a constructivist statement merely holds that ‘people do one thing and non the other due to certain ‘social constructs’ : thoughts, beliefs, norms, individualities or some other interpretive filters through which people perceive the worlds’ . Subsequently, a qualitative, interpretative attack to epistemology is adopted. Gratton and Jones ( 2010 ) argue nevertheless that this attack carries agnosticisms, due to the subjective nature of construing people’s ideas. As such it is evident that this philosophical attack is non suited for the research undertaking.
At discrepancy, philosophic pragmatism in general is defined by Phillips ( 1987, p. 205 ) as ‘the position that entities exist independently of being perceived, or independently of our theories about them.’ Schwandt ( 1997, p.133 ) builds upon this saying “scientific pragmatism is the position that theories refer to existent characteristics of the universe. The realist attack adopts an epistemology of quantitative every bit good as qualitative measurings affecting instance surveies and or convergent interviewing ( Gratton and Jones, 2010 ) . The usage of quantitative analysis is seen to take the accent on reading and is hence more precise.
After briefly measuring two applicable philosophical models, this undertaking will utilize a realist attack which adopts an epistemology of quantitative every bit good as qualitative measurings. Research approaches such as studies, interviews, SPSS package attacks and Multiplier analysis will be used. By following a ‘multi-method’ attack allows for more assurance in the analysis phase due to more informations aggregation methods, otherwise known as ‘Triangulation’ . This signifier of triangulation used is more specifically ‘Methodological triangulation, which refers to the usage of more than one method for garnering information’ ( Deacon, Bryman and Fenton, 1998 ) .
3.2 | Research Design
3.2.1| The ‘Sample’
‘In order to measure the economic impact of a installation you need to specify what economic part you are analysing’ ( Brownrigg, 1974 ) . Crompton ( 1995 ) high spots that when carry oning an impact survey, the visitant disbursement should merely be acknowledged, as such the geographic country of the survey normally relates to metropolis boundaries. Those who live locally must be screened out and eliminated from the study’s computations. ‘If respondents study they are local occupants, there is no point in them finishing any more of the questionnaire because the information they provide will non be used’ ( Crompton, 2010 ) . In this undertaking the defined country of involvement is decided as the boundary environing the Milton Keynes ‘MK’ postal codification country (see Appendix 1) . This is the country North of Leighton Buzzard, South of Wellingborough, West of St. Neots and East of Brackley. The incorporation of local providers in countries such as Buckingham and Bedford was the logical thinking behind utilizing the MK postal codification.
3.2.2 | The Method
In order to determine the greatest possible result for this survey, non merely does the direct impact of extra disbursement demand to be accurate, but besides the right multiplier must be applied ( Downward et al, 2009 ) . The LM3 multiplier as explained above requires an in depth extent of fiscal information ( ‘3’ unit of ammunitions of disbursement ) . Furthermore with partial entree to required fiscal information to finish a LM3 multiplier it would be appropriate to carry through this undertaking utilizing a LM2 multiplier. ‘LM2 takes in to consideration all the procedures of an LM3 multiplier, nevertheless minus one unit of ammunition of disbursement – the LM2 enables you to look at the immediate local economic impact of a specific administration or enterprise over a period of two rounds’ ( Sacks, 2002, p.83 ) . Round one is the income of the administration and Round two is how it spends its turnover ( re-investing in the local economic system ) ( Sacks, 2002 ) .
The procedure of finishing the LM2 multiplier will be undertaken through ; a questionnaire issued to sing fans and an interview with John Cove the Chief Executive of MK Don’s. First the questionnaire ( see Appendix 2 ) will be distributed out to 150-200 off fans over a choice period of games, which will take to detect the demographics and passing form of sing fans. These games will be 7ThursdayFebruary 2015 versus Bristol City, 21stFebruary 2015 versus Peterborough and 21stMarch 2015 versus Notts County. Furthermore the informations collected from this will so be imported in to statistical analysis package ( SPSS ) , which will assist to place mean and direct outgos. Furthermore, utilizing SPSS allows for the designation of similarities between fan types which will assist to do decisions about which fan classs invest the most money at Stadium MK.
Second, the disbursement study ( Appendix 3 ) will be used to collate the information from John Cove in the interview scheduled for Friday 20ThursdayMarch 2015. The usage of the disbursement study will make a formal closed interview to achieve the relevant fiscal information to cipher the LM2 multiplier. It is expected that Mr.Cove will be able to help with all of the units of extra disbursement.
3.2.3 | Research Analysis
In order to cipher the 2nd unit of ammunition of disbursement which is needed to finish the LM2 multiplier, MK Don’s turnover, and the turnover which is so re-spent in to the local economic system must be identified. This information will be gathered through secondary informations ; through the agencies of MK Don’s fiscal statement. The statement for the accounting twelvemonth stoping 30ThursdayJune 2014 presents the bowls one-year turnover and outgo on providers and employees. In add-on, John Cove will supply informations about the per centum of turnover spent on local providers and local employees to cipher the 2nd unit of ammunition of disbursement to bring forth the LM2 multiplier shown in Equation 1.
Once the LM2 Multiplier has been attained it is so possible to specify the economic impact through this. The economic impact is equated through utilizing the turnover, direct outgo and LM2 multiplier. First, as shown in Equation 2, turnover will be multiplied by the multiplier to observe how much money Stadium MK adds into the local economic system.
Second, direct outgo will be multiplied by the multiplier and the figure of place games MK Don’s drama ( 23 ) , to determine the economic impact of Stadium MK over one season ( Equation 3 ) . Direct outgo is critical to include so that exaggerating the economic impact does non turn out an issue.
3.4 | Research Quality
Weaver, K. and Olson, J. ( 2006 ) . Understanding paradigms used for nursing research.J Adv Nurs, 53 ( 4 ) , pp.459-469.
Alston, P. ( 1989 ) . Epistemic Justification: Essaies in the Theory of Knowledge. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Ordnancesurvey.co.uk, ( 2014 ) . OS OpenData Supply – Download or order Ordnance Survey OpenData. [ on-line ] Available at: hypertext transfer protocol: //www.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/opendatadownload/products.html [ Accessed 11 Nov. 2014 ] .
Peck, R. , Olsen, C. and Devore, J. ( 2005 ) .Introduction to statistics and informations analysis. Belmont, CA: Thomson Brooks/Cole.
Parsons, C. ( 2010 ) . “Constructivism and Interpretative theory” ; In Theory and Methods in Political Science, 3rd Ed. ( Palgrave Macmillan ) ; P. 80.
Harvey, F. ( 2006 ) . Ontology. In B. Warf ( Ed. ) ,Encyclopedia of Human Geography. ( pp. 341-343 ) . Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, Inc